06 Premises issues
Local cinemas come in all shapes and sizes, in converted old buildings, new purpose built designs or re-claimed former cinemas. This chapter explores the plethora of ownership, licensing and regulatory issues which relate to managing a venue.
Finding suitable premises
The key tasks here are firstly to locate potential premises, and then to assess their suitability for your planned purposes. There are a number of options for locating vacant premises:-
- Local newspapers
- Local authorities – often keep a register of vacant commercial premises
- Estate Agents – particularly those who specialise in commercial property
- Internet searches
You may be looking for a leasehold, freehold or a vacant site for a new building. Before you start looking at properties make a list of your basic minimum requirements as a checklist.
Tenure issues – the perils and pitfalls of leases
The whole basis of ownership and occupation of land and buildings is different under Scottish law. The following section relates mainly to England.
Having freehold ownership of the building, by and large entitles you to peaceful occupation and, planning restrictions aside, leaves you free to do what you want when you want. You also do not have to pay rent and so the on-going revenue costs (loans or equity finance) are more controllable. There may even be parts of the building you can rent out to other businesses in order to generate additional income. However, the most common type of ownership is a commercial lease.
Leasehold ‘ownership’ – a peculiarity of English law, dates back to feudal times and ensures that land and property ownership remains in the same hands from generation to generation. As a leaseholder you do not own the property in perpetuity as you do with a freehold. You ‘own’ it for a specified length of time (the ‘term’) during which you have similar kinds of rights of occupation and access as a freeholder.
You pay once for the lease (the ‘premium’) and you also pay rents to the freeholder who may vary these on a regular basis with no ceiling on what may be charged. You are also usually liable to pay for all repairs to the building and these must be carried out to a minimum standard by an approved contractor within a given time frame. At the end of all this, once the term of the lease expires you own nothing. While leasehold agreements these days are rarely constructed to deliberately mislead the unwary, you need to think very carefully before entering into such an agreement. The golden rule is, have a solicitor look at it for you and don’t sign anything until you have your finance lined up. While many clauses are standard, don’t think of the lease as a boring bit of bureaucracy. Read it carefully and ask your solicitor to explain anything that isn’t entirely clear.
This is a one-off capital sum which some, highly sought after leases may attract. Generally, a high premium is often offset by a low rent and vice versa. For difficult to sell leases, there is unlikely to be a premium and in the cinema business, it is unusual to pay a premium.
In theory, a long lease is better than a short one as you have security of tenure and it becomes more worth your while to invest in the property. However, on a long lease you are generally liable for the rent for the full term regardless of what happens. Even if the lease allows you to transfer (assign) it to someone else during the term, you may still be required to underwrite the rent. In the case of a Limited Company, it is not uncommon for the landlord to ask for personal guarantees from the Directors or even another organisation (e.g. the local authority) if he deems the company ‘risky’ i.e. especially one without a trading track record.
The lease usually either prevents you assigning it entirely or requires permission from the landlord to do so. Even if you are able to find someone who wishes to acquire the lease from you, the landlord may not give permission or may require you to underwrite the rent in case the assignee defaults.
Most standard leases are what are known as ‘full repairing and insuring’ leases. This means that the lessee is responsible for buildings insurance and all repairs to the fabric of the building during the term.
There is also generally a standard clause which requires the lessee to hand the property back to the freeholder at the end of the term in the same condition as when it was acquired. This means not only making good the more obvious damage through wear and tear, but may also require the lessee to undo ‘improvements’ he may have made to the property while occupying it. For example, the property which was once open plan offices which the lessee converted to individual offices, may be required to be turned back to an open plan arrangement before it is handed back.
Almost all leases make provision for the landlord to periodically raise the rent – generally every 5 years although sometimes shorter or longer periods are specified. It is not uncommon for rents to double, treble or quadruple at rent reviews and there is no ceiling on what can be charged. The only right of appeal is through an independent arbitration process which generally attempts to establish what the going rate, or market rent is for premises in that area. It will also need to take account of the frequency of review and general trends in property prices. A market rent is simply a rent that someone is willing to pay and so, while you may feel that the rise is extortionate, if the landlord can demonstrate that this level of rent is being paid elsewhere nearby, arbitration is unlikely to find in your favour. In fact, it may even determine that the new rent should be raised further and so there is an element of risk in going to arbitration.
Restrictive covenants are additional clauses in leases which prevent the purchaser from doing certain things. A problem in recent years for a number of campaigns to save former cinemas after they were acquired and closed down, has been a restrictive covenant imposed on sale of the lease, preventing the building being used as a cinema again. It may be possible to negotiate removal of such clauses (for example through payment of a fee) but if the vendor will not compromise, there is very little you can do. This issue in some more unusual cases, also applies to freeholds (it is not uncommon for example for certain religious organisations to prohibit the sale of alcohol in premises which were previously used as churches).
This applies to both freeholds and leaseholds; you need to be very careful to ensure that you know about any finance agreements with banks and other lenders that are secured on the asset. Your conveyancing solicitor will advise but you may well need the asset to be unencumbered so that you can raise additional finance on it. It is always useful to have some collateral up your sleeve for contingencies.
Most external alterations, extensions and changes of use require planning permission. Particular care is required in conservation areas. You should ensure that you have the necessary consents before you start work, as planning enforcement action can be taken, even if you have obtained Building Regulation approval.
Where a building is ‘listed’ because of its particular historical or architectural characteristics, listed building consent is required for all internal and external works, including those affecting non-original parts of the building. You should note that unauthorised work to a listed building is a criminal offence. Building Control Surveyors ensure that buildings are constructed in accordance with the conditions of the planning permissions and listed building consent.
You should contact the planning department of your local authority to find out whether your proposal needs consent. It can take several weeks or months to obtain planning consents depending on the complexity or controversial nature of what you are proposing. Fees can be a significant cost (several hundred pounds) and you may also need to employ an architect to draw up plans. You will be required to post statutory notices for a specified period describing the proposed change adjacent to the premises in order that objections can be lodged with the local authority.
Getting a building listed can be a useful means of preserving a site from demolition and/or development. A significant number of cinema buildings, particularly those from the art deco era are listed buildings. The downside is that once a building has been listed it becomes more difficult to make changes to both the interior and exterior as permission has to be given by the local authority. Historic England and Historic Environment Scotland are the main national bodies with the task of identifying and protecting the nation’s architectural inheritance, which they do by recommending ‘listing’ or earmarking the most important buildings.
The Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) or the Scottish Government make the final decisions on listing. The following section details processes applicable in England and broadly similar procedures and regulations apply in Scotland.
What does listing mean?
The word ‘listing’ is a shorthand term used to describe one of a number of legal procedures that help Historic England to protect the best of our architectural heritage. When buildings are listed they are placed on statutory lists of buildings of ‘special architectural or historic interest’ compiled by the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, on advice from Historic England. Listing ensures that the architectural and historic interest of the building is carefully considered before any alterations, either outside or inside are agreed
Why are buildings chosen?
Listed buildings are selected with great care. The main criteria used are:
- architectural interest: all buildings which are nationally important for the interest of their architectural design, decoration or craftsmanship; also important examples of particular building types and techniques, and significant plan forms
- historic interest: this includes buildings which illustrate important aspects of the nation’s social, economic, cultural or military history
- close historical association with nationally important buildings or events
- group value, especially where buildings comprise an important architectural or historic unity or are a fine example of planning (such as squares, terraces and model villages). The older and rarer a building is, the more likely it is to be listed. Post-1945 buildings have to be exceptionally important to be listed. Buildings less than 30 years old are only rarely listed, if they are of outstanding quality and under threat.
Why are there three grades?
Listed buildings are graded to show their relative importance:
- Grade I buildings are those of exceptional interest
- Grade II* are particularly important buildings of more than special interest
- Grade II are of special interest, warranting every effort to preserve them
There are over 370,000 list entries currently protected by listing, and of those by far the majority – over 92% – are Grade II. Grade I and II* buildings may be eligible for Historic England grants for urgent major repairs. Currently there are about 150 listed cinema buildings in England although a number do not operate as cinemas any longer.
How to get a building listed
Requests for individual buildings to be spot-listed can be made to The Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport at any time although priority treatment will be given to those which are under threat. It is important to draw attention to any new evidence which may explain why the building’s special interest has previously been overlooked. It is best for all involved if buildings are assessed for possible listing before planning permission has been granted for redevelopment, since last minute listing can cause difficulties and additional expense if it takes place without warning. The thematic listing programme is designed to help reduce this risk.
What is the procedure?
Requests to list buildings should be sent to Historic England, full information including application form guidance notes are on the Historic England website. As well as your reasons for wanting the building listed, you should include:
- a location plan showing, wherever possible, the position of any other listed buildings nearby
- clear, up-to-date photographs of the main elevations of the building
- any information about the building, e.g. date built
- details of specialised function (such as industrial use)
- historical associations
- the name of the architect
- the building’s group value in the street scene
- details of any interior features of interest
- the daytime telephone number of the owner or his or her agent who may be able to give access to the building for an inspection.
Historic England and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) aim to complete the whole process within five months.
How to appeal against listing
There is no statutory right of appeal, but if you think your property is not special enough to be listed, you can write to the Department of Culture Media and Sport. If you are planning an appeal the Department can provide a guidance note on the criteria used in considering listing appeals. Because listing appeals are non-statutory, applications for de-listing are not normally considered if a building is the subject of an application for listed building consent or an appeal against refusal of consent, or where a local authority is has to take action against the owner because of unauthorised work or neglect.
copyright Historic England
You are now required to attain a single licence from your local authority. The 2003 Licensing Act removed the requirement for cinemas to have a separate Cinematograph licence, or for mixed arts venues to have a Public Entertainments licence. Instead, film is categorised as a ‘licensable activity’ under the act and organisations need to apply for a Premises licence from the local licensing authority (usually your local council).
The licensing authority will normally grant this licence for your cinema to screen films that have been certified by the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC). Cinemas looking to screen films that have not been BBFC certified will generally have to submit these separately to the local licensing authority for local certification.
This licence for your premises should not be confused with the content licences obtained from film distributors that enable you to screen their films. Cinemas are required to obtain a theatrical licence agreement from the relevant distributor for each film that they screen. Film societies and other exhibitors in non-traditional cinema venues, need to obtain a non-theatrical licence (see the information in non-theatrical exhibition).
Before you can open your doors to the public you will need to carry out a Fire Safety Risk Assessment. You can find downloadable guidance for completing this assessment (published by the Department for Communities and Local Government) online here.
As with health and safety requirements, it is preferable to invite an inspection of your premises and plans prior to contracting for any building works. In theory your architect will know what the rules are, but it may still be worth checking that a certificate will be issued once the work is done. In the course of such an inspection they may also pick up on other things which need attention. Once open and running, as with licensing, fire authorities will visit from time to time to inspect the premises to ensure compliance with the law but also to familiarise themselves with the premises in the unlikely event of a major incident.
Health and safety
The local authority’s rules relating to Premises Licences do not in any way replace or reduce the underlying statutory duty of employers to comply with the requirements of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. This legislation requires, amongst other things, an assessment of the risks to staff, patrons and others who may be affected by their business and identification of measures required to control or avoid the risks.
Local authorities are responsible for monitoring compliance with this legislation, usually through their Environmental Health services. It is advisable to involve the Health and Safety Inspectorate at the earliest opportunity, especially if you are undertaking building works.
Safety certificates you may require include mechanical & electrical, ceiling, heating and ventilation and various insurances that must be kept up to date as a condition of a cinema licence and an operational building.
You will need a licence from the PRS to cover the playing of music on the films’ soundtrack. PRS is paid at 1% of net box office after VAT for the use of the composers and publishers of music. You are also likely to need a licence from PPL for use of recordings and DVDs for ambient music played in the foyer and auditoria. The UKCA (UK Cinema Association) have negotiated a reduced rate (20% discount) PPL licence scheme for all UK cinemas that is based on the number of cinema screens you will be operating. You will need to negotiate directly with the PRS.
Restaurant and liquor licences
Concession sales (confectionary, popcorn, ice cream, etc.) often bring in more sales than the film screenings in commercial cinemas and can be a crucial income stream for any cinema. However, if you are planning anything other than sweets and crisps i.e. hot food, you will need planning permission and a restaurant licence. Licensing for alcohol sales is a separate matter and you will have to put in a licence application with the local licensing justices. A liquor licence will only licence consumption of alcohol in the bar (and seated at tables in the restaurant if you have one). If you want your customers to be able to take alcohol into the auditorium you have to get separate permission.
The purpose of the Building Regulations is threefold:
To ensure reasonable standards of:
- Health and Safety for persons in or about the buildings
- Energy Conservation
- Access and facilities for people with disabilities
The technical requirements of the Regulations and guidance on how to meet them are contained in Approved Documents, available from the Planning Portal. These cover a number of areas including structure, fire safety, resistance to the passage of sound, toxic substances and the conservation of fuel and power. It is important to remember that the contents of the Approved Documents are only guidelines i.e. they are not cast in stone and there may be some flexibility in their interpretation. Your architect and/or builder should be fully up to speed on Building Regulations, so you should not have to deal directly with this aspect.
Summary of key points from Chapter 6
- Before looking for premises draw up a list of your minimum basic requirements
- Always employ a solicitor to help you navigate the perils and pitfalls of leasehold agreements
- While listing a building may confer some benefits in terms of preservation, it also means it may be more difficult to get planning consents
- Make contact with your local authority’s Fire Officer as soon as you can. What he or she requires may have significant implications for your budget
- You are likely to require several different licences including a premises licence, a fire certificate, a restaurant licence, a liquor licence, and licences for use of copyright protected music
- Get in touch with your Local Authority’s planning officers and environmental health department at an early stage, to sound them out on your proposals